Current:Home > reviewsWest Virginia governor signs vague law allowing teachers to answer questions about origin of life -PrimeFinance
West Virginia governor signs vague law allowing teachers to answer questions about origin of life
View
Date:2025-04-14 17:57:16
CHARLESTON, W.Va. (AP) — West Virginia Republican Gov. Jim Justice signed a law Friday that supporters say promotes the free exchange of ideas in science classrooms, despite objections from opponents who said the vaguely worded measure could allow for the incursion of religion into public schools.
The legislation allows public school teachers to answer student questions “about scientific theories of how the universe and/or life came to exist.”
It was proposed after Republican Senate Education Chair Amy Grady, a public school teacher, said fellow educators have told her they don’t feel comfortable answering questions about theories outside evolution because they don’t know if doing so is permissible.
Speaking to the bill on the Senate floor in January, Grady said the bill is meant to clarify how teachers can approach these situations.
“This says, ‘If a student asks you questions about a theory that they’ve read about or they’ve heard about — maybe it’s not a popular theory, but a theory — you can discuss it,’” she said.
She said the bill is “encouraging our students to think, encouraging our students to ask questions, encouraging our teachers to be able to answer them.”
What is unclear is what kinds of teaching would be protected by the bill, which does not define what a “scientific theory” is.
Grady proposed a bill last year that would have specifically allowed intelligent design to be taught in public school settings. This year’s bill contained similar language when it was first proposed. It was reworked early in the legislative session to remove any direct mention of intelligent design before even being put in front of lawmakers.
After the bill was altered, two high school students speaking in support of the bill in front of Grady’s committee said they wanted it passed so educators could have the option of offering teaching on intelligent design in addition to evolutionary theory — not as a requirement or a replacement for it.
Teaching about intelligent design in public schools has been controversial for decades.
Proponents of intelligent design contend that many features life of life and the universe are too complex to have evolved from natural selection and must have been created by an intelligent designer. That designer could be, but does not have to be, identified as God. They also claim that intelligent design is a scientific theory.
Others have argued that intelligent design is just creationism in a new package. A federal court in Pennsylvania ruled in 2005 that a public school could not require the teaching of the concept because intelligent design “is not science” and that it “cannot uncouple itself from its creationist, and thus religious, antecedents.”
Hurricane High School juniors Hayden Hodge and Hunter Bernard, both 16, said they are both religious but that intelligent design is not a religious argument and does not mention anything about God.
“I am not advocating for Biblical Creationism, or Adam and Eve, or the Muslim and Jewish narrative. This is not a biblical narrative,” Hodge said, adding later: “Why not allow teachers to offer students multiple views? Students deserve to hear a multiple of theories and then follow which is more reasonable.”
The National Center for Science Education said in a statement that the legislation is “threatening the integrity of science education in the state’s public schools.”
Aubrey Sparks, legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union of West Virginia, said the organization would be watching the law’s implementation closely. If the wording of the legislation is ambiguous to her, she said, it’s going to be ambiguous for teachers, students and parents, too.
Staff is in the process of creating a portal for families to report concerns if they do see instances of religious teaching in public schools, Sparks said.
“They pass things like this to try and institutionalize the place of religion in public schools,” she said. “If they wanted to keep religion and public schools separate, then they wouldn’t pass laws like this one.”
When the bill passed the Senate in January, Democratic Sen. Mike Woelfel said he has no problem with anyone’s religious beliefs and that as a Catholic, he thinks God created life. But he said he doesn’t think that’s something that should be taught in public schools and expressed concern that the legislation could be used as a backdoor approach to do so.
He asked Grady if the law would permit teachers to educate students about intelligent design, and she said yes. The definition of what constitutes a “scientific theory” is not included in the bill, Woelfel said.
“What I do have a problem with is the constitution, which says, ‘If you have a bill, it’s got to be specific. It can’t be vague,’” he said. “People need to know what the bill says so they can follow the bill.”
The Seattle-based Center for Science and Culture, the leading organization advocating for intelligent design acceptance and research, is against public schools teaching the concept.
Instead, the organization pushes for public school policies “protecting teacher academic freedom to discuss the scientific strengths and weaknesses of evolution without getting into alternative theories like intelligent design,” Center Associate Director Casey Luskin said.
He said supporters’ “priority with intelligent design is to see it grow and develop as a science.”
“When it gets brought into public schools, that politicizes the issue, and that politicization leads to witch hunts and discrimination against pro-ID scientists and faculty in the academy,” he said.
The academic freedom approach, however, is “legal and helps greatly improve student learning.”
veryGood! (9464)
Related
- Trump wants to turn the clock on daylight saving time
- Former high-ranking Democratic legislator in New Mexico pleads not guilty in federal fraud case
- Morgan Wallen defends Taylor Swift from booing fans after joke about the singer's Eras tour
- Rape case dismissed against former Kansas basketball player Arterio Morris
- Spooky or not? Some Choa Chu Kang residents say community garden resembles cemetery
- Court upholds California’s authority to set nation-leading vehicle emission rules
- Man indicted in attempt to defraud 28 US federal bankruptcy courts out of $1.8M in unclaimed funds
- Sophia Bush Says She’s “Happier Than Ever” After Personal Journey
- South Korea's acting president moves to reassure allies, calm markets after Yoon impeachment
- Assistant principal charged with felony child abuse in 6-year-old's shooting of teacher
Ranking
- Mets have visions of grandeur, and a dynasty, with Juan Soto as major catalyst
- Russ Cook, Britain's Hardest Geezer, runs length of Africa in 10,000-mile epic quest for charity
- Helen Mirren's Timeless Beauty Advice Will Make You Think of Aging Differently
- Oliver Hudson admits he was unfaithful to wife before marriage: 'I couldn't live with myself'
- Brianna LaPaglia Reveals The Meaning Behind Her "Chickenfry" Nickname
- Conjoined twins Abby, Brittany Hensel back in spotlight after wedding speculation. It's gone too far.
- Black-owned children's bookstore in North Carolina is closing over alleged threats
- Soon to be a 2-time Olympic host city, Salt Lake City’s zest for the Games is now an outlier
Recommendation
Could Bill Belichick, Robert Kraft reunite? Maybe in Pro Football Hall of Fame's 2026 class
March Madness winners and losers: ACC, UConn, Cinderellas led NCAA Tournament highlights
Right to abortion unlikely to be enshrined in Maine Constitution after vote falls short
Mega Millions winning numbers in April 9 drawing: Jackpot climbs to $97 million
Bill Belichick's salary at North Carolina: School releases football coach's contract details
Arizona Supreme Court rules abortion ban from 1864 can be enforced
Jessica Alba steps down from The Honest Company after 12 years to pursue 'new projects'
California student, an outdoor enthusiast, dies in accident on trip to Big Sur