Current:Home > NewsA robot was scheduled to argue in court, then came the jail threats -PrimeFinance
A robot was scheduled to argue in court, then came the jail threats
View
Date:2025-04-13 05:07:06
A British man who planned to have a "robot lawyer" help a defendant fight a traffic ticket has dropped the effort after receiving threats of possible prosecution and jail time.
Joshua Browder, the CEO of the New York-based startup DoNotPay, created a way for people contesting traffic tickets to use arguments in court generated by artificial intelligence.
Here's how it was supposed to work: The person challenging a speeding ticket would wear smart glasses that both record court proceedings and dictate responses into the defendant's ear from a small speaker. The system relied on a few leading AI text generators, including ChatGPT and DaVinci.
The first-ever AI-powered legal defense was set to take place in California on Feb. 22, but not anymore.
As word got out, an uneasy buzz began to swirl among various state bar officials, according to Browder. He says angry letters began to pour in.
"Multiple state bars have threatened us," Browder said. "One even said a referral to the district attorney's office and prosecution and prison time would be possible."
In particular, Browder said one state bar official noted that the unauthorized practice of law is a misdemeanor in some states punishable up to six months in county jail.
"Even if it wouldn't happen, the threat of criminal charges was enough to give it up," he said. "The letters have become so frequent that we thought it was just a distraction and that we should move on."
State bar organizations license and regulate attorneys, as a way to ensure people hire lawyers who understand the law.
Browder refused to cite which state bar in particular sent letters, and what official made the threat of possible prosecution, saying his startup, DoNotPay, is under investigation by multiple state bars, including California's.
In a statement, State Bar of California Chief Trial Counsel George Cardona declined to comment on the probe into DoNotPay but said the organization has a duty to investigative possible instances of unauthorized practice of law.
"We regularly let potential violators know that they could face prosecution in civil or criminal court, which is entirely up to law enforcement," Cardona said in a statement.
Leah Wilson, the State Bar of California's executive director, told NPR that there has been a recent surge in technology-based legal representation that has emerged to fill a void in affordable legal advice.
"In 2023, we are seeing well-funded, unregulated providers rushing into the market for low-cost legal representation, raising questions again about whether and how these services should be regulated," Wilson said.
Even if the use of AI in court was not being challenged, some observers have questioned just how effective DoNotPay's AI tools would be for people in need of legal services, with some having mixed to shoddy results attempting to use its basic features.
Browder has been known for drumming up attention with stunts. Earlier this month, he claimed on Twitter that the company would pay any lawyer $1 million to argue in front of the U.S. Supreme Court wearing AirPods that would pipe AI-generated arguments from its "robot lawyer."
Founded in 2015, DoNotPay has raised $28 million, including funding from prominent venture capital firm, Andreessen Horowitz, according to analytics firm PitchBook.
Pivoting away from AI legal defense amid threats
Instead of trying to help those accused of traffic violations use AI in the courtroom, Browder said DoNotPay will train its focus on assisting people dealing with expensive medical bills, unwanted subscriptions and issues with credit reporting agencies.
Browder also still hopes it is not the end of the road for AI in the courtroom.
"The truth is, most people can't afford lawyers," he said. "This could've shifted the balance and allowed people to use tools like ChatGPT in the courtroom that maybe could've helped them win cases."
The future of robot lawyers faces uncertainty for another reason that is far simpler than the bar officials' existential questions: courtroom rules.
Recording audio during a live legal proceeding is not permitted in federal court and is often prohibited in state courts. The AI tools developed by DoNotPay, which remain completely untested in actual courtrooms, require recording audio of arguments in order for the machine-learning algorithm to generate responses.
"I think calling the tool a 'robot lawyer' really riled a lot of lawyers up," Browder said. "But I think they're missing the forest for the trees. Technology is advancing and courtroom rules are very outdated."
veryGood! (2395)
Related
- Brianna LaPaglia Reveals The Meaning Behind Her "Chickenfry" Nickname
- A landmark appeals court ruling clears way for Purdue Pharma-Sackler bankruptcy deal
- Powering Electric Cars: the Race to Mine Lithium in America’s Backyard
- Inside Clean Energy: Think Solar Panels Don’t Work in Snow? New Research Says Otherwise
- What do we know about the mysterious drones reported flying over New Jersey?
- ¿Por qué permiten que las compañías petroleras de California, asolada por la sequía, usen agua dulce?
- Toxic Releases From Industrial Facilities Compound Maryland’s Water Woes, a New Report Found
- A New Project in Rural Oregon Is Letting Farmers Test Drive Electric Tractors in the Name of Science
- Macy's says employee who allegedly hid $150 million in expenses had no major 'impact'
- Carlee Russell admits disappearance, 'missing child' reported on Alabama highway, a hoax, police say
Ranking
- Man can't find second winning lottery ticket, sues over $394 million jackpot, lawsuit says
- The OG of ESGs
- Jenna Dewan and Daughter Everly Enjoy a Crazy Fun Girls Trip
- Penelope Disick Gets Sweet 11th Birthday Tributes From Kourtney Kardashian, Scott Disick & Travis Barker
- 'Vanderpump Rules' star DJ James Kennedy arrested on domestic violence charges
- Save 45% On the Cult Favorite Philosophy 3-In-1 Shampoo, Shower Gel, and Bubble Bath
- Has inflation changed how you shop and spend? We want to hear from you
- This Program is Blazing a Trail for Women in Wildland Firefighting
Recommendation
'Survivor' 47 finale, part one recap: 2 players were sent home. Who's left in the game?
What cars are being discontinued? List of models that won't make it to 2024
Why Tom Hanks and Rita Wilson Are One of Hollywood's Best Love Stories
Hollywood writers still going strong, a month after strike began
NFL Week 15 picks straight up and against spread: Bills, Lions put No. 1 seed hopes on line
Penelope Disick Gets Sweet 11th Birthday Tributes From Kourtney Kardashian, Scott Disick & Travis Barker
'Like milk': How one magazine became a mainstay of New Jersey's Chinese community
Judge Upholds $14 Million Fine in Long-running Citizen Suit Against Exxon in Texas